Libby's Italian Pastry Shop Menu (Update 2025)

Libby's Italian Pastry Shop in New Haven, CT, is a must-visit for those with a sweet tooth craving authentic Italian desserts. The menu boasts a variety of cookies, cakes, cannolis, and gelato flavors that will satisfy any dessert lover. Customers rave about the cappuccino and hazelnut gelato, as well as the indulgent cookies and cream cannoli. The charming indoor and outdoor dining spaces provide a cozy ambiance to enjoy your treats. With a wide range of pastries and gelato flavors to choose from, Libby's offers a delightful experience for all. Don't miss out on their delicious desserts after enjoying a meal in Little Italy - you won't be disappointed.

Desserts

Cannoli Siciliani

$3.20

Flavored Cannoli Sicilian

Cannoli Napolitano

$3.25

Sfogliatelle

Pasticiotti

$3.25

Cream Puff

Italian Eclair

Rum Baba

Dipped Bigne

Dipped Eclair

Carrot Cake

Cheesecake

$5.25

Italian Cheese Cake

Chocolate Mousse Square

Spument

Mochaccino

Profiterole

Peach Melba Suprema

$6.00

Lobster Tail